Add Grains vs Adobe Photoshop

Compare Add Grains with Adobe Photoshop for adding authentic film grain to your photos. See why a free, specialized grain tool beats a $22.99/month subscription for grain effects.

Winner

Add Grains

Free online film grain editor with 34+ authentic film stock emulations, real-time preview, and complete browser-based privacy.

Pros

  • +100% free, no subscription
  • +34+ authentic film stock emulations
  • +Browser-based, no install required
  • +Photos never leave your device
  • +Real-time preview with instant results

Cons

  • -Focused specifically on grain and film effects
  • -No RAW file support
  • -Requires web browser

Adobe Photoshop

Industry-standard photo editing software with comprehensive tools including Add Noise filter and Camera Raw grain controls.

Price: $22.99/month

Pros

  • +Industry-standard comprehensive editor
  • +Multiple grain methods available
  • +Full creative control with layers and masks
  • +Professional retouching capabilities

Cons

  • -$22.99/month subscription required
  • -Steep learning curve for grain workflow
  • -Grain filters produce synthetic-looking noise
  • -Requires powerful hardware

Our Verdict

For adding authentic film grain specifically, Add Grains delivers more realistic results for free. Photoshop's noise filters produce synthetic patterns that lack the organic character of real film emulsions. Unless you need Photoshop's comprehensive editing tools, Add Grains is the clear choice for grain effects.

Winner: Add Grains

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureAdd GrainsAdobe Photoshop
Pros
  • 100% free, no subscription
  • 34+ authentic film stock emulations
  • Browser-based, no install required
  • Photos never leave your device
  • Real-time preview with instant results
  • Industry-standard comprehensive editor
  • Multiple grain methods available
  • Full creative control with layers and masks
  • Professional retouching capabilities
Cons
  • Focused specifically on grain and film effects
  • No RAW file support
  • Requires web browser
  • $22.99/month subscription required
  • Steep learning curve for grain workflow
  • Grain filters produce synthetic-looking noise
  • Requires powerful hardware

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Photoshop replicate real film grain accurately?

Photoshop's Add Noise filter and Camera Raw grain tool generate mathematical noise patterns that approximate grain but do not replicate the organic structure of actual film emulsions. They lack the tonal variation and cluster patterns found in real film stocks like Portra or Tri-X.

Is Add Grains better than Photoshop for grain?

For grain specifically, yes. Add Grains offers 34+ authentic film stock emulations that reproduce the actual grain characteristics of real film, whereas Photoshop provides generic noise filters. However, Photoshop is a far more comprehensive photo editor for tasks beyond grain.

Can I use Add Grains and Photoshop together?

Absolutely. Many photographers apply grain using Add Grains and then import the result into Photoshop for further editing. This combines the best of both tools: authentic grain from Add Grains and powerful editing from Photoshop.

How much does Photoshop cost compared to Add Grains?

Photoshop requires a Creative Cloud subscription at $22.99/month ($275.88/year). Add Grains is completely free with no subscription, no ads, and no account required.

Try Add Grains Free

The best free alternative for adding film grain to your photos.

Open Editor