Kodak Tri-X 400 vs Ilford HP5 Plus

The ultimate showdown between the two legendary black and white films

Kodak Tri-X 400

The legendary black and white film used by countless photographers since 1954, known for its classic grain and contrast

Price: $10-12 per roll

Pros

  • +Iconic, classic grain structure
  • +High contrast for punchy images
  • +Excellent push processing
  • +Rich midtones

Cons

  • -More expensive than HP5
  • -Higher contrast may not suit all subjects

Ilford HP5 Plus

Versatile black and white film with finer grain and more moderate contrast, popular for its value and flexibility

Price: $8-10 per roll

Pros

  • +More affordable
  • +Finer, more uniform grain
  • +Smoother tonal gradations
  • +Very versatile

Cons

  • -Less distinctive character
  • -Lower contrast may need adjustment

Our Verdict

Both are exceptional films with devoted followings. Tri-X offers more classic grain character and contrast, while HP5 is more versatile and budget-friendly. The choice often comes down to personal preference.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureKodak Tri-X 400Ilford HP5 Plus
Price$10-12 per roll$8-10 per roll
Pros
  • Iconic, classic grain structure
  • High contrast for punchy images
  • Excellent push processing
  • Rich midtones
  • More affordable
  • Finer, more uniform grain
  • Smoother tonal gradations
  • Very versatile
Cons
  • More expensive than HP5
  • Higher contrast may not suit all subjects
  • Less distinctive character
  • Lower contrast may need adjustment

Try Add Grains Free

The best free alternative for adding film grain to your photos.

Open Editor